ESTABLISHING HIGH STANDARDS IS PUTTING THE CART BEFORE THE HORSE
ESTABLISHING HIGH STANDARDS IS PUTTING THE CART BEFORE THE
HORSE
By Domenick J. Maglio Ph.D. Traditional Realist
There should not be anyone against the raising of standards
especially educational standards. Usually when standards and expectations are
more demanding, it motivates individuals to reach them. The person or
organization is supposed to be energized.
However, the motivation turns into a disincentive when
standards are so unreasonable that only the chosen few can possibly meet them.
Resentment skyrockets when no matter how hard the person or group tries, the
objective cannot be accomplished. The fundamentals of training the individual
have to be examined before we expect the impossible.
Any leader or administrator should provide the training, skills
and discipline needed to obtain the prescribed standards. Many of our schools do
not have discipline but rather are in chaos. This and the lack of laying the
necessary foundation before establishing high standards are foolhardy. It is as
if asking youngsters to accomplish Olympic records in running speeds when they
have not physically developed and have not been trained in running techniques.
Our ruling politicians and educational experts have arrived
at a ridiculous consensus. They think by the magical act of proclaiming high
educational standards our entire national educational system would become
competitive with other nations. PISA (Programe Internationale Standard
Assessment) has ranked the United States 24rd in science, 21st
in reading and 31st in math compared to other developed countries.
This is nothing to brag about.
“No Child Left Behind” under President Bush and “Common Core”
under President Obama were federally directed attempts to raise student
performance by establishing higher national education standards. They
coordinated with individual states establishing their own unrealistic
standards. The results of the state experiments have not and will not
significantly increase the performance of the students.
The essential reason students’ academic performance varies
from one country to another is their preparation. Students need a strong
foundation in the lower grades to build upon. Individual students mature at
different rates. They set their goals differently and may decide they want to
finally excel academically. Unless they work hard in a safe environment to fill
in the voids in their skills and overall knowledge they cannot be successful.
The earlier the filling in the gaps process takes place in
the elementary grades the better the chances of their meeting their
expectations of doing well. In the classroom the teacher must accurately
evaluate the student’s ability in each area. The emphasis must be on reading,
writing and arithmetic.
The 3Rs are necessary to move forward. Without the ability
to read the child cannot do mathematical word problems or follow directions. Basic calculation skills have to be mastered
in order to be competent in more advanced math. A student has to learn how to
express himself orally and on paper in all disciplines to obtain higher levels
of academic performance.
Developing the motivation to do something without these
necessary skills is foolhardy. It sets the child up for failure. Young children
think they can do almost anything until they try. Then and only then the
reality check of not being able to do it helps them listen and follow the adult’s
directions. This happens with a parent at home and a teacher at school.
Too many students and their parents have been duped by grade
inflation. Both think high grades mean competency in the subject. This is not
the case. It is a politically correct means of deceiving the parents of the
poor quality of education. This ploy might temporarily satisfy most although it
will not reverse the decline in education. Throwing more money at the problem has
not worked. We are already spending more total money on education than any
other nation.
The ruling class should not continue to put the cart before
the horse. Instead we need to encourage changes
that have to start in the early years. First, grade integrity based on
performance has to be reestablished. The mastery of the 3Rs should be the basis
of the curriculum instead of social engineering programs that avoid the
individual student needs. Schools have to be reduced in size to make them more
manageable.
The federal government should stop kicking our dysfunctional
education system down the road but allow local communities to regain their
power to solve the low school performance in their unique circumstances. Local
school boards should take the initiative to bring back the common sense changes
that were in place when we were at the top of the education pyramid. Our
constitution left education to the states through the local government for well
thought out reasons.
Citizens should start by electing levelheaded, concerned
people of character not people who want to begin their political careers.
Changes in our educational approach need to emanate from the classroom not the
bureaucracy in Washington,
DC.
DC.
Domenick J. Maglio, PhD. is a columnist carried by various
newspapers, an author of several books and owner/director of Wider Horizons
School, a college prep program. You can visit Dr. Maglio at
www.drmaglio.blogspot.com.