MANHATTAN INSTITUTE STRATEGY PREVENTS URBAN DECADENCE
MANHATTAN INSTITUTE STRATEGY PREVENTS URBAN DECADENCE
By Domenick J. Maglio PhD.
Traditional Realist
It is hard to believe once beautiful cities like San
Francisco, Los Angeles and New York City have turned into hellholes. There are
bums, currently called “homeless,” injecting illegal drugs in front of the
public. These vagrants do not follow the acceptable protocol of public health.
They urinate and defecate on the sidewalks and lie down in public places to
sleep. Incredibly annoying and frightening, they no longer beg for a handout
but threaten people for their money.
When the police are in the vicinity of these disgusting acts
of anti-social, criminal behavior, even they turn a blind eye. Law enforcement
no longer enforces the law. These out-of-control loiterers and law-breakers
have somehow become a “protected class” that is being allowed to dismantle once
quaint, historic cities in the United States.
All three of these cities have progressive leaders condoning the
policies of lawlessness.
The think tank, The Manhattan Initiative for Policy
Research, developed a theory called “The Broken Window.” It found a connection
between disorder, fear, crime and urban decay. Besides emphasizing the
relationship between enforcing lesser crimes such as breaking of windows, it tends
to place criminals on notice that the police will actively enforce all laws no
matter how inconsequential. A major component of the Broken Window approach was
to take the police out of their patrol cars and put them on the city streets to
become an integral part of the community.
The officers develop relationships with the local youngsters
and private citizens. They were supposed to become involved with local
community leaders to develop programs to reverse the hostility directed at the
community. They developed ways for neighborhood citizens to receive positive
recognition for building better communities for everybody.
This partnership between law enforcement and the neighborhood
was the key to significantly lowering crime rates in New York City in the 1990s
during Mayor Rudy Giuliani’s administration. Violent crime declined by 56% as compared
to only 28% in the rest of the nation. Felonies in the subways dropped 75%.
This community partnership with police in the neighborhood enforcing all the
laws, even the minor ones led to a healthier, safer and more orderly city.
Yet when we go online to look up the “Broken Window”
phenomenon the progressives have used every angle to attribute the positive
results of declining crime to anything but the Broken Window law enforcement
strategy. Some of these critics have gone so far as to rename it “The Broken
Window Fallacy.” The stakes in denying this strategy of combatting crime are
great.
There is no way that New Yorkers and tourists did not see
the positive changes in Times Square, the subway and other parts of Manhattan
landmarks in the 1990s. The local
residents witnessed community stability return to their own block. All the
boroughs were more peaceful places to live after the Broken Window approach was
instituted.
On the other hand the effects of not enforcing basic health
rules, decent behavior towards others and laws protecting the rights of others cannot
be hidden. The relaxing of common decency towards tourists, allowing the
homeless infestation, abusing police in once fashionable neighborhoods is startling.
Tent cities that form on sidewalks and block local businesses create appalling
sights and health conditions and have reintroduced diseases under control for decades
are the result.
The glibbest progressive politicians cannot erase these
vivid pictures of dying cities. The mayor of New York City, Bill Deblasio,
seems to relish his destruction of one of the greatest cities of the world.
Sadly a large block of progressive voters are willing to walk over the cesspool
of druggies, petty criminals, mentally ill and homeless in the name of
“tolerance.” Many others are voting with their feet by relocating to the
suburbs leaving the devastation for others to experience. Until hipster urban dwellers
realize that these socialist policies are eroding the pride New Yorkers have
for their great city it will continue to slide into chaos.
The Broken Window enforcement makes it advantageous to do
the right thing while making it painful to do the wrong one. Clear, concise
messages of how to improve ones’ life are better than utopian socialist double
talk. No one, especially government can improve your life. Throughout our
history, discipline and the work ethic of the individual have brought minorities
up the economic ladder.
The Broken Window philosophy will work today as it has in
the past. It is tough love but is better than lies that degrade the dignity of people
for the sake of another government handout. These “freebies” lead to dependency
and loss of personal initiative and freedom.
Domenick Maglio, PhD.
is a columnist carried by various newspapers, an author of several books and
owner/director of Wider Horizons School, a college prep program. Dr. Maglio is
an author of weekly newspaper articles, INVASION WITHIN and a new book
entitled, IN CHARGE PARENTING In a PC World. You can see many of Dr.
Maglio’s articles at www.drmaglio.blogspot.com.
Labels: broken window theory, Guiliani, Manhattan Initiave